Digital Natives? Digital Immigrants? How does an Immigrant Educator Find the Proper Balance?
Okay, no one is going to be surprised that I’m a digital
immigrant. (At least according to Marc Prensky’s Don’t Bother Me Mom – I’m Learning!) I’ve been in the tech country
awhile, but I still can find myself out of my comfort zone when it comes to new
technologies. I definitely still suffer bouts
of culture shock as well. When I first
discover a new technology, I can be in the classic honeymoon phase and love the
possibilities it all brings – but I often get homesick for my old ways pretty
darn fast when I start to get frustrated when learning takes more time than I
seem to have at the moment. (Which is often!) The good news, though, is once I find the
proper use – I typically feel at home again.
Why is it then– that I’m
beginning to rethink the level of my technology travel as an educator?
After reading Prensky’s viewpoints as well as other
materials and opinions regarding digital natives and immigrants – I found
myself with many points to ponder. I
work with college students all day. I am
acutely aware that they often seem to have a different way of looking at
things. Sometimes, I’ll admit, it makes me a little crazy. They often want immediate feedback; they
won’t answer an email as fast as a text or IM, etc. Everything should be in app or infographic form
– they often don’t prefer anything with heavy text. Also, I’m told they make fun of people like me
on airplanes who still carry and read hard copies of books. (I have a fear of
being trapped on a long flight and my technology stops working – leaving me
with nothing to read.) This thought,
they tell me, would never occur to them.
They have a trust in technology that I may never have – in fact, after
completing this reading and others on the subject – I have begun to ponder the
idea that they have trust in a lot of things that I don’t have. I knew the digital age made them perhaps a
little more efficient than I was in completing a task such as getting a study
group together (via texting or IM), or quickly finding the cheapest place to
buy an item, etc., but I don’t know that I ever really thought too terribly
much about how they are really truly approaching their lives differently and even
may hold different values because of the new technology. They see the world
differently. It is smaller and larger at the same time. Though they may not
necessarily know how to use every technology tool out there, many do seem less intimidated
by the thought of giving it a try, and think the world is a better place
because of it.
Having said this, what’s the bottom line for me? I’m hoping that I don’t have more questions
than answers. I’ve always realized that
I need to reach my students where they are – but - after this week’s readings
and research - I believe that I may have a better understanding of how important
it is to use 21st century learning techniques to do just that. Not to say that old (immigrant)
techniques don’t still have value - but I may need to be more student centered
than I have been…and blended classrooms seem to make more sense to me now. I need to utilize, and actually sometimes
embrace, the technology that students bring to class with them every day. But where does one start? How does a teacher discover and then learn to
use new literacy technologies that makes sense to the content they are
teaching– making sure the students are truly getting the basic fundamentals
that they need? How does one ensure that
students know how to critically think about all of the information that they
have coming at them 24/7? How can they
be taught that reflection can be necessary? What about teaching morals and
empathy that often are learned by spending real time with real people? What about truly having interaction with
those from other cultures and all walks of life to gain heartfelt insight
necessary for global citizenship?
I know
there is a balance to strike between the old and the new and I suppose I’m on a
clearer journey now to find it. As I
said, it’s no surprise that I’m an immigrant - I just thought I’d been in the
country a little longer than I had.
Speaking of Digital Immigrants, be sure to check out my Infographic below -
Speaking of Digital Immigrants, be sure to check out my Infographic below -

I feel a lot like you. I teach high school and every day they have a new way to do something. I also agree with the trust issue that I have. I think that many of us, non-millennials back in the day had a computer crash and we have lost everything, we didn't have it backed up on a "cloud". So it makes sense that we don't trust technology 100%.
ReplyDeleteI also just like the feel of a book! There is something about the smell of the paper.
Marilyn,
ReplyDeleteI so enjoyed reading your reflection--thanks for being transparent. I think that one of the biggest changes that technology has brought to us is the ability to act quickly when someone says, "I don't know" or "I wonder if, how, whether, etc." In my head, this is a fundamental game changer. So for those of us who were knowledge imparters . . . Google and the internet can be a bit threatening. However, if we can develop inquisitiveness and curiosity in ourselves and in students, I think this will pave the way for effective and pragmatic uses of technology in classrooms or wherever learning is occurring.
BTW, I was once 12 hours away from turning in a paper that I had typed using Word Perfect (while letters on black screen) when I accidentally reformatted my floppy disk. Today when I use Google, I occassionally find myself trying to save a document I'm working on even though it is autosaved . . .